The Undroppables - The Art of Dynasty | Chapter 14 (Productive Struggle)

Building a dynasty fantasy football team requires strategic thinking and football acumen similar to planning a long military campaign. You must intimately understand your leaguemates’ rosters and tendencies, diligently prepare for the rookie draft and waiver wire, and thoughtfully craft a balanced yet versatile roster aligned to your vision. Knowing when to push all chips to the table for a title run or temporarily rebuild for sustained excellence is equally critical. The finest dynasty owners combine sharp situational analysis with statistical rigor and old-fashioned football study to construct juggernauts that dominate their leagues for years.

This guide outlines core tenets to help you architect a formidable roster poised for both immediate and enduring success. By internalizing essential dynasty strategies around planning, preparation, roster construction, and pivoting between competing goals, you too can rule over your leaguemates year after year like a battle-tested emperor of old.

Fantasy football is a dynamic and ever-evolving game that requires strategic thinking and adaptability. While many managers focus on immediate success, there’s a viable alternative approach known as the Productive Struggle strategy. This strategy centers around deliberately sacrificing short-term gains to build a strong foundation for sustained success in the long run. In this comprehensive guide, we will explore the principles, benefits, and implementation strategies of the Productive Struggle strategy in fantasy football.

What is the Productive Struggle?

Productive Struggle, a concept invented by Ryan McDowell, refers to a strategy in fantasy football where managers intentionally prioritize long-term gains over short-term success. It involves building a team by acquiring young, high-upside players and draft capital while being patient with the development process.

Why Consider Productive Struggle?

The running back position is often volatile and injury-prone, making it risky to heavily invest in it. By emphasizing young, talented players, managers can secure a foundation for long-term success and minimize the risk associated with aging veterans. This strategy aligns well with dynasty and keeper leagues, where rosters carry over from year to year.

Align with Your League Format

The Productive Struggle strategy is only effective in dynasty and keeper leagues, where long-term planning is crucial. Rosters carry over, allowing managers to develop and grow their teams over multiple seasons. The strategy’s focus on acquiring young talent aligns with the goals of these league formats. It does not apply to season-long leagues or DFS formats.

The Virtue of Long-Term Thinking

Success with the Productive Struggle requires patience, as the benefits may not be immediately evident. The process can be tiresome and a wrong step can set you back years. Managers must be willing to endure short-term setbacks for long-term gains and tread carefully. Most importantly, staying committed to the process and the vision is crucial. Making impatient or irrational moves are the death knell of the Productive Struggle.

Emphasize Youth

A core principle of the Productive Struggle is to acquire young, ascending players with significant upside. Identify rookies or second-year players, particularly wide receivers, who have shown promise or possess the potential to break out. These players can develop into long-term cornerstones of your team. While you want to focus on youth, you need to avoid investing heavily in the running back position early on in the Productive Struggle process. Even if you are acquiring (or drafting) a 21-year-old RB, if he doesn’t fit well into your timeline to being competitive, you may miss the prime window of that player’s production.

Scouting Young Talent: Prioritize players in their first or second year who have demonstrated potential or are in a position to take on larger roles.
Wide Receiver Focus: Concentrate on acquiring young wide receivers who often have longer career spans compared to running backs.
Timeline Alignment: Ensure that the players you acquire fit within your projected timeline to competitiveness, maximizing their impact when your team is ready to contend.

Maximize Draft Capital

Accumulating early-round draft picks is essential in the Productive Struggle strategy (see Chapter 5 – Iron Bank). Higher draft picks provide opportunities to select top-tier prospects with high potential. This increases your chances of landing impact players who can contribute significantly to your team. As the hit rates of rookie picks are not especially high, even with early picks, you need to maximize your chances of landing impact players in your rookie drafts by accumulating as many darts in the early first round.

Trading for Picks: Actively seek trades that allow you to acquire additional first and second-round picks.
Draft Strategy: Use these picks to target high-upside rookies, particularly those who have strong draft capital (value insulation) and/or landed in favorable situations (value acceleration).
Diversification: Diversify your picks across multiple positions to balance risk and maximize potential returns.

Balance Immediate Production & Long-Term Potential

While the focus is on the future, it is important to understand that you will need to develop a competitive roster. If you are always chasing youth without a plan to get to contender level, you’ll be stuck in an eternal rebuild. Look for a balance between players who can contribute immediately and those who provide long-term upside. This ensures your team will be building to a position of strength. Generally, a correctly executed Productive Struggle should result in a strong team within 2-3 years.

Veteran Presence: Include a few reliable veterans who can provide stability and immediate production.
Future Outlook: Ensure that your core is built around young talent with the potential to develop into stars.
Transitional Phases: Plan transitional phases where you gradually shift from a youth-focused roster to a competitive mix of youth and experience.

Work the Waiver Wire

Stay vigilant in monitoring the waiver wire and free agency, actively looking for potential breakout players or undervalued assets. This means being willing to take risks on unproven players who have shown flashes of potential, even if it means enduring some short-term struggles. By identifying and acquiring players before their breakout performances, you can gain a competitive advantage over your opponents. Identify emerging starters or players who are gaining increased opportunities. Actively add these players to your roster to bolster your team’s long-term potential.

Regular Monitoring: Check the waiver wire frequently for players who are trending upwards or gaining new opportunities.
Risk Assessment: Be willing to take calculated risks on unproven players who show potential.
Long-Term Investment: Focus on adding players who can contribute to your long-term success, even if they don’t produce immediately.

Chess Moves

Another aspect of the Productive Struggle is engaging in strategic trades to acquire players who may be undervalued or overlooked. This could involve trading away a consistent but less explosive player in exchange for someone with higher upside but greater uncertainty. By making calculated trades that prioritize potential long-term gains over short-term stability, you increase your chances of securing game-changing players who can significantly impact your team’s performance.

Identify Trade Targets: Look for players who have high potential but are undervalued due to current situations or past performance.
Sell High: Trade away consistent but lower-upside players when their value peaks.
Risk vs. Reward: Balance the potential risks and rewards of each trade to ensure long-term benefits outweigh short-term losses.

Trade Established Players for Draft Picks

Seek opportunities to trade established players for draft picks or young talents. Evaluate players whose value may be at its peak and leverage that value to secure long-term assets. This approach helps maintain a continuous influx of young talent into your roster.

Peak Value: Identify players on your roster whose value is at its highest and consider trading them.
Future Assets: Aim to acquire high draft picks or young, promising players in return.
Continuous Reloading: Keep a pipeline of young talent flowing into your roster to sustain long-term success.

Leverage Knowledge & Research

Stay informed about college prospects, draft analysis, and player development trends. Identify talented players before they become household names. Exploit their potential before their value skyrockets, allowing you to acquire them at a more affordable price.

College Scouting: Follow college football closely to identify future NFL talent.
Draft Analysis: Utilize draft guides and expert analysis to stay ahead of the curve.
Development Trends: Monitor player development trends to spot breakout candidates early.

Find the Right Balance

Striking the right balance between short-term competitiveness and long-term development is crucial. Invest in immediate contributors while focusing on the long-term potential of your roster. Continuously evaluate your team’s strengths and weaknesses to maintain competitiveness while building for the future (See Chapter 4 – Ship Chasing).

Roster Evaluation: Regularly assess your roster to ensure a balanced mix of youth and experience.
Strategic Investments: Make strategic investments in players who can provide immediate help and long-term value.
Ongoing Adjustment: Continuously adjust your strategy based on your team’s performance and emerging opportunities.

Stay Active & Adaptable

Fantasy football is dynamic, and strategies must adapt to changing circumstances. Stay active on the waiver wire, monitor player performances, and seize opportunities to improve your team. Adapt your strategy based on new information, emerging trends, and opportunities that arise throughout the season (see Chapter 10 – Bayesian Inference).

Active Management: Be proactive in managing your roster and making necessary changes.
Trend Analysis: Keep up with trends and player performances to make informed decisions.
Flexibility: Be flexible and willing to adapt your strategy as new opportunities arise.

Continuous Evaluation

Regularly evaluate your roster to identify underperforming players or veterans whose value may decline. Be proactive in making adjustments and acquiring players who align with the long-term vision of your team. Stay active in player evaluation, monitor trends, and adapt your strategy accordingly. Even when you turn your team into a contender, the Productive Struggle strategy continues as you can continuously reload talent using the core principles.

Performance Review: Regularly review player performance and make necessary adjustments.
Proactive Moves: Stay ahead of declines by trading or cutting underperforming players.
Long-Term Vision: Keep your long-term vision in mind with every move you make.

Trust the Process

The Productive Struggle strategy requires patience, foresight, and a long-term vision. Embrace the challenge and enjoy the process of constructing a team with long-term potential. Find satisfaction in the growth and development of your roster over time.

Patience: Understand that success takes time and remain patient throughout the process.
Commitment: Stay committed to your long-term vision, even during short-term struggles.
Enjoyment: Take pleasure in the journey of building a competitive team for sustained success.

By emphasizing youth, maximizing draft capital, and making calculated trades, managers can create a foundation of high-upside players for future seasons. While it requires patience and a long-term vision, the benefits of this strategy can be significant. Remember to align the strategy with your league format, stay active in player evaluation, and enjoy the process of constructing a team for long-term success.

Please support us on Patreon!

The Art of Dynasty | Chapter 14 (Productive Struggle)